Astro vs React

Astro vs React

What is Astro and how Astro is compared to React.

ยท

9 min read

Astro:

Astro is a new static site generator created by the Vercel team. Some key points about Astro:

  • Astro uses Astro Components which are lightweight HTML, CSS and JavaScript components.

  • Astro generates static HTML sites which means they are fast, secure and cost-efficient to host.

  • Astro components are similar to React components but more lightweight since they generate static HTML.

  • Developing Astro sites is simple. You create Astro components in the /src folder, start a dev server and build a production site.

  • Astro uses Tailwind CSS out of the box for styling.

  • You can import any npm package within your Astro components.

  • Astro sites are static so they are deployed to any static hosting provider.

  • Astro aims to provide a modern framework for building marketing sites, documentation sites, blogs and other static content.

In summary, Astro is a new static site generator focused on:

  • Simplicity

  • Performance

  • Productivity

It uses the idea of lightweight Astro Components to make building static sites fast and easy. Overall Astro provides an alternative to traditional static site generators like Jekyll, Hugo and Gatsby.

React:

  • React is a JavaScript library for building user interfaces.

  • React apps are client-side rendered, not static HTML. They are dynamic and interactive.

  • React uses virtual DOM for efficient re-rendering which makes it fast.

  • React components are more complex than Astro components. They support state, lifecycle methods, context API etc.

In summary:

  • Astro is ideal for static marketing sites, blogs, documentation sites etc.

  • React is ideal for data-driven apps with interactivity, real-time updates and complex states.

  • Astro is faster and more lightweight since it generates static HTML.

  • React apps have more features but require a backend and are not static HTML.


How to use Astro

Astro is free and open source. Here are the steps to use Astro in your development process:

  1. Install Astro: You can install Astro using NPM.
npm install -g @astrojs/cli
  1. Create an Astro project:
astro create my-project

This will create a new Astro project with the default starter template.

  1. Edit the Astro components in the /src folder. Astro components are just HTML, CSS and JavaScript.

  2. Start the Astro dev server:

astro dev

This will start a dev server at localhost:3000 where you can view your site as you develop.

  1. When ready, build your Astro site:
astro build

This will generate a production-ready static site in the /dist folder.

  1. Deploy the /dist folder to any static hosting provider like Vercel, GitHub Pages, Netlify etc.

  2. Astro sites are static HTML so they are:

  • Fast

  • Secure

  • Cost-efficient to host.

So in summary, Astro provides a very simple workflow for developing static sites using Astro Components. The installation, development and build process is straightforward and optimized for productivity.


Dynamic Components

Astro can also be a dynamic website. Astro is a hybrid static site generator, which means that it can generate both static and dynamic websites.

To create a dynamic website with Astro, you can use the following features:

  • Astro components: Astro components can be used to create reusable components that can be rendered either statically or dynamically.

  • Astro integrations: Astro integrations can be used to connect to external APIs and data sources. This allows you to populate your website with dynamic data.

  • Astro serverless functions: Astro serverless functions can be used to generate dynamic content on the server. This is useful for creating pages that need to be updated frequently, such as product pages or blog posts.

To create a dynamic website with Astro, you would typically start by creating Astro components for your website's layout and content. You can then use Astro integrations to connect to external APIs and data sources. Finally, you can use Astro serverless functions to generate dynamic content on the server.

Once you have created your Astro application, you can build it using the astro build command. This will generate the static HTML, CSS, and JavaScript files for your website. You can then deploy these files to a web server.

Here are some examples of dynamic websites that can be created with Astro:

  • E-commerce websites

  • Blog websites

  • News websites

  • Social media websites

  • Portfolio websites

If you are looking for a hybrid static site generator that can be used to create both static and dynamic websites, then I recommend Astro. Astro is a powerful tool that can help you to create fast, scalable, and secure websites.


Back-end for Astro

For an Astro based static website, you do not need a traditional backend. Since Astro generates static HTML files, you can simply deploy the generated HTML, CSS and JavaScript to any static hosting provider.

Some options for hosting an Astro static site are:

  • Vercel: The team that created Astro also created Vercel. Deploying to Vercel is very simple and integrated into the Astro CLI.

  • Netlify: Another popular option for hosting static sites. Netlify has good integration with GitHub for automatic deploys.

  • GitHub Pages: A free hosting option provided by GitHub. You can host your Astro site from a GitHub repository.

  • Cloudflare Workers: You can use Cloudflare Workers as a serverless backend for your Astro site. Workers can perform server-side rendering, fetch data, etc.

  • Firebase hosting: Google's Firebase platform provides hosting for static sites.

  • Any other static hosting provider: Since Astro sites are just static files, you can host them on any provider that hosts static HTML.

So in summary, for an Astro static site, you do not need a traditional backend like Node.js, PHP or Python. You just need a provider to host the static HTML, CSS and JavaScript files that Astro generates. The hosting providers I mentioned above are good options.


Form Handling

To handle forms and form data in an Astro static site, you have a few options:

  1. Use a third-party form handling service:
  • Services like Formspree, GetForm and FormSubmit can handle form submissions and send the form data to your email. You just embed their form code in your Astro component.

  • This is the simplest option since you don't need a backend. But you are dependent on the third-party service.

  1. Use Cloudflare Workers:
  • As I mentioned earlier, Cloudflare Workers can act as a serverless backend for your Astro site.

  • You can write a Cloudflare Worker that listens for form submissions and handles the form data. This gives you full control.

  • You will need to configure your Astro form to submit to your Cloudflare Worker URL instead of an email.

  1. Use a headless CMS as a backend:
  • Headless CMSs like Sanity.io, Forestry and DatoCMS allow you to manage content without a traditional backend.

  • You can configure a headless CMS to also handle form submissions and store the form data.

  • Your Astro form will submit to an endpoint provided by the headless CMS.

So in summary, there are a few good options for handling forms in an Astro static site - using a third-party form service, Cloudflare Workers or a headless CMS. Each option gives you varying degrees of control over the form data and flexibility in how you process it.


Back-end API

You can build a backend in Ruby, Python, PHP or Go to work with your Astro static site. Here are the high-level steps to build your backend:

  1. Build your backend API:
  • You can build a backend API using any of these languages - Ruby on Rails, a Flask API in Python, or a Go web service.

  • The API will be responsible for handling data - storing, retrieving and updating. It can also handle tasks like sending emails.

  1. Expose endpoints for your Astro site to consume:
  • Your backend API will expose endpoints for your Astro site to fetch data from. For example, an endpoint to fetch blog posts or an endpoint to handle form submissions.

  • The endpoints can return JSON data that your Astro site can consume.

  1. Fetch data from the API in your Astro components:
  • In your Astro components, you can make HTTP requests to your backend API endpoints to fetch the data you need.

  • You can use Astro's <script> tags or fetch() to make the requests and consume the JSON response.

  1. Submit form data to an API endpoint:
  • When a user submits a form to your Astro site, you can make a POST request from your Astro component to submit the form data to an API endpoint you expose.

  • Your backend can then process the form data however you need - store it in a database, send an email, etc.

So in short, you can build a traditional backend API using any language (Ruby, Python, PGP, Go, etc) to provide an offsite data source and interactivity for your Astro static site. Astro components just consume the API endpoints via HTTP requests to fetch and submit data.


Astro Usability

Here are my thoughts on Astro's maturity and usability for building website frontends:

Pros:

  • Astro is a relatively new and modern framework, so it uses the latest web technologies like JavaScript, Tailwind CSS and Astro Components.

  • The Astro build process to generate static HTML is very fast and optimized for performance. This is ideal for websites.

  • Astro's component-based architecture makes it easy to build reusable components and organize your website templates.

  • Astro has good integration with data sources like headless CMSs, APIs and Markdown files. This makes it easy to populate your website templates with dynamic data.

  • Astro has a small but growing ecosystem of tools, libraries and integrations that make it useful for building websites.

Cons:

  • Astro is still a young framework, so the ecosystem is not as mature as frameworks like React or Vue. There are fewer libraries, tools and tutorials currently.

  • Debugging issues can sometimes be tricky since Astro generates static HTML. You don't have a full dev server like in React.

  • Astro is still changing and evolving, so some things may change or break between major versions currently.

Overall, I think Astro shows a lot of promise for building website frontends. The strengths around performance, component architecture and data integration make it a good fit. However, being a new framework, there are some maturity and ecosystem issues currently.

So I would recommend Astro for simpler websites where you value performance and simplicity over a large ecosystem of tools. But for more complex websites, a more mature framework like React may be a safer choice currently due to the larger ecosystem and community support.


Disclaim: This article was created using Rix (that is an AI bot). This is not a full lecture you can use to make a website. It is just a study to understand where is Astro compared with React. Learn and prosper ๐Ÿ––

Did you find this article valuable?

Support Software Engineering by becoming a sponsor. Any amount is appreciated!

ย